Skip to content

Day four: marking the VIPs in your email

Part 04 of 8

On this page

The check took forty seconds again this morning. The pass down the feed went quicker than yesterday’s, because you’ve stopped bracing before each line. What’s left of the hour is the half hour these two weeks have been holding back for. It’s the first time you tell Point something. So far you’ve watched what Point decided.

Yesterday finished with a piece of paper. Names on it, written down without any thought at all. Names are how you’ve always known which thread is which. The list of people whose mail you can’t afford to miss has been running your business for years. So far it has lived in one place, which is your own head.

Today it gets written down and entered. The entering takes about ten minutes. The writing down takes the other twenty, and every one of them earns its place. Draw the list badly and you’d have been better off with nothing. What a star does to the ranking, who belongs on one and where its reach ends are all in VIP mail that never gets buried. This page is the half hour itself, in the order it goes. It also tells you what tomorrow morning looks like, which is a morning with nothing to check.

Write the list before you open the screen

Paper first. The contact list in Point comes second. That order changes the answer more than you’d think.

A screen full of names you recognize is a persuasive document. Open it before you’ve decided anything and you start editing somebody else’s list instead of writing your own. You agree and disagree with what’s in front of you. The question you sat down to ask, which is who’s missing, goes quiet. You star the familiar names because they’re there to be starred. The names you sat down to protect are the ones the screen leaves out. It’s the same discipline that kept you off the autonomy dial on Monday, on a gentler screen: decide first, then go and look.

The question that produces a usable list is a narrow one. Everyone you work with matters, and that’s why you work with them. So ask a smaller thing. Whose message, left sitting for three days while you got on with something reasonable, costs you something you can’t buy back? That has a shape you can check against. Money that goes away. A deadline that’s final once it’s gone. Work you get offered once.

Then read the names off something, rather than out of memory. Memory hands you the people you dealt with this week, and those are the ones you’d have caught anyway. Three places between them hold the real answer:

  • Yesterday’s paper. The threads you opened even though the summary was good. You ran that test on yourself already, without meaning to.
  • Who has paid you, and who’s about to. The last few invoices out and the next few in. An invoice shows you consequence more plainly than a feeling does.
  • The last quarter of your calendar. Anyone you gave an hour of your working day to was worth an hour of your working day.

Anything that turns up in two of the three is on the list. Expect somewhere between six and a dozen names. Past twenty, you’ve quietly answered a different question, and what a long list costs you is the part of the VIP guide worth reading before you go further.

The names your history cannot see

Three mornings of watching have earned you something you can spend now.

The ranking already knows your regulars. It got them right on Tuesday and Wednesday with nothing from you. Who you answer fastest and who you’ve written to longest both sit in eleven years of mail, and that’s a reasonable guess at who matters. So a star on the client you email twice a day is a vote for a candidate who has already won. The star is fine there. Your half hour pays somewhere else.

A star is worth most where the mail is thin. So go down your list. Beside each name, write roughly how many messages the two of you have exchanged in the last year. Leave the number rough. The small ones are the entries doing the work:

  • The introducer who writes twice a year, and each time it’s worth a quarter of your income.
  • The client you’re mid-pitch with. A complete stranger in June, and the largest thing on your desk in August.
  • The bank, the insurer, the regulator, the landlord. You hear from them rarely, and usually once something is already running against a clock.
  • Whoever covers for you when you’re away. They write in the one week they have to, and that’s the week it counts.

That’s close to the opposite of how the list wants to write itself. The instinct is to star the people you think about most. Those are the people you exchange the most mail with. A ranking built on history has already found them. The names carrying their weight here are the thin ones. AI email triage, and whether you can trust it sets out how much of that gap a reader of the message alone can close. Your star closes another piece of it by hand, in advance, with knowledge that lives outside the mail.

One thing sits at the far end of all this, and today is a better time to learn it than October. A list of people you correspond with holds the people you correspond with. The first email from a regulator you’ve never dealt with, or the inquiry from a lawyer who was handed your name last week, gets caught a different way. A ranking reads the message and forms a view about a sender it has never seen, which is how email triage works. That part runs on its own, whatever you write on your paper today. Your list sits on top of it as one good input.

Ten minutes on the contact list

Now open contacts in Point. Everybody you deal with has been sitting there since Monday.

They arrived with the mailbox. The duplicates a decade builds up were merged on the way in. So the client who writes from a phone, an office address and something ending in gmail.com is one person here. That matters more today than it did when you connected. The star goes on the person. It holds wherever they write from, including an address they write from for the first time.

One star against each name on your paper. That’s the whole operation, and ten minutes covers it. Go past that and you’ve started doing something else.

Two things to leave alone while you’re in there. The first is ranking. Keep the list flat, and keep it flat in your head too. A list with degrees of importance in it is the ranking you already had, rewritten smaller and by hand. A name is on the list or off it.

The second is undoing Tuesday. You starred one person on the second morning, when their message turned up somewhere you’d have walked past. That name may be missing from today’s paper. Leave the star where it is. You set it on evidence, on a particular morning, about a particular message that went astray. Evidence like that outranks a list you wrote from three sources on a Thursday.

Then set your expectations for tomorrow, because this is the one place people misread the result. Your feed tomorrow looks a lot like your feed today. A star raises how much a message matters, not how quickly it needs answering. So an ordinary note from a starred client lands at the top of what can wait, marked as mattering, and it sits there while you finish what you were doing. Why important and urgent are not the same is the reasoning underneath that, and it’s the difference between reading Friday morning as a success or as a failure.

Two smaller cases, if either is yours. If you connected a second business on Monday, give it a second list of its own. The people who can create a deadline in one business usually carry their standing nowhere else, and keeping two businesses apart is what that separation covers. And if somebody else works the same mail, the marks belong to whoever sets them. So the list is worth agreeing out loud across the desk before you each enter your own. Covering for each other is what happens on the week one of you is there alone.

Nothing happens tomorrow

This is the honest part. It’s why today sits awkwardly in two weeks of measuring.

Every change so far has paid out by the next morning. You connected on Monday and the feed was sorted on Tuesday. You corrected a summary on Wednesday and the next one from that sender came back the new way. Today you change something real and tomorrow stays quiet, and that’s the list behaving exactly as you drew it. You filled it on purpose with people who write rarely. Half those names may send you nothing for a month.

So Friday leaves you with nothing to check, and a day like that carries one specific temptation. You go and change something else, so there’s something to watch. Leave the dial where it is. It has sat where you found it since Monday, and this morning told you about names. It says nothing about filing, drafting or scheduling, and setting how much your inbox does on its own deserves a decision of its own rather than a mood. Today’s change is the whole of today’s change.

What you’re waiting for is a small and thoroughly ordinary event. It’s worth knowing its shape, so you recognize it when it turns up. Something plain from one of those names, on a day that’s already busy. Photos from a site visit with no question in them. A two line thank-you with one sentence at the end about next year. Those used to go under, and they went under while you were doing something entirely reasonable, which is what makes them so hard to notice losing. Now they sit at the top of what can wait, with your judgment attached to them, until you get there. Most of what makes that morning good comes from somewhere other than your list, and the whole of what Point does is the rest of it.

Two housekeeping notes before the paper goes in a drawer.

Copy the names onto whatever you wrote Tuesday’s two numbers on, with today’s date beside them. In ten days you’ll want to know what you told Point and when. That’s the difference between two weeks you can account for and a feeling that things seem better.

And put a date on the calendar for the end of the quarter, to read the list again. Every star stays until you take it off. A star set for one large job in the spring is still doing its work at Christmas, and you’re the one who notices which of those names have gone quiet.

Read the list one more time

Before the paper goes away, look at the names again. Ask what they have in common, beyond mattering.

Frequency is out, because you chose half of them for writing rarely. Money is out too, because the bank is on there and the bank pays you nothing. Here’s what they share. Every one of them gets a careful reply from you. You draft their answers in your head on the walk back from the car. You write, reread, change a word, and reread it again before it goes.

Which is where the morning actually goes now. Finding the mail took forty seconds. Ranking it was done before you sat down. Working out what was in it was a line you read and believed. The time that’s left is writing back. It gathers almost entirely in the names you just starred. Careful replies are slow, slow replies get put down, and the ones you put down are the ones this whole list exists to keep in view. That’s a circle, and better sorting keeps you inside it.

Tomorrow you open one of those threads and a reply is already sitting in it. Point wrote it, out of eleven years of your mail, and the words are doing their level best to sound like you. The draft waits for you, because you left every setting where you found it on Monday.

That’s a stranger thing to be handed than a sorted inbox. It’s the first thing in these two weeks you’ll want to argue with, sentence by sentence.

Ready for a calmer inbox?

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.

Private beta

What you're joining

It runs on the mail you have

Point sits on top of Gmail or Outlook. Your address, your history and your contacts stay exactly as they are, so there is nothing to migrate.

You set how much Point does

Out of the box everything waits for your review, replies included. You hand over only what you trust, one kind of work at a time.

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.