Skip to content

How to prioritize your email (when there is too much of it)

Part 05 of 7

On this page

The chapter before this one left an ask on the table, and it’s the one everything so far has been resting on. Putting your mail into tidier piles is the easy half. The ask is whether an inbox can do the weighing well enough that you’d trust it with the one message that could cost you a client. For as long as anyone has run a small firm, the honest answer was no. That’s why every method any of us was taught leaves you in the chair, doing the ranking by hand.

The answer is yes now. It’s also what people are after when they go looking for how to prioritize their email. They want a way to decide what to deal with first when there’s far too much of it to weigh one message at a time. So here it is plainly, and then the Tuesday this series opened on, run a second time.

Where the usual advice stops

Go looking for a way to prioritize a full inbox and you meet the same four answers. Flag or star the ones that matter, so they stand out from the rest. Name your best clients as priority senders, so their mail rises into a lane of its own. Build folders, action and waiting and read-later, and put every message into one of them. Or run the Eisenhower split, urgent against important, and take the urgent-and-important first.

Disciplined people run all four, and all four are sound. Each one asks the same thing of you. A flag helps only once you’ve read the message and judged it worth flagging. Folders sort what you’ve already sorted. A list of names covers the people you thought to write down in advance. It has further limits worth knowing before you lean on it, all set out in VIP mail that never gets buried.

The Eisenhower split is a genuinely good way to think, and that’s exactly the trouble. Something still has to put each of two hundred and forty messages into one of the four boxes. That something is you, every morning, from nothing, while the clock runs. Important versus urgent makes the case for keeping those two questions apart, and it repays reading before you let anything answer them on your behalf.

So the advice stops a step short, every time. It hands you a tidier rulebook for a job that was always too big for a working day. The second chapter found that fault in the inbox itself, a flat list where a coupon and a note that could end a relationship carry the same weight. The fourth chapter found the same treadmill underneath inbox zero, wearing a better name. Here it is a third time, in the advice people give about it.

The ranking stops being yours

Which isn’t a technique you adopt. It’s a job you stop doing.

Everything needed to put that Tuesday’s message first was already sitting in Nadia’s mailbox, and that chapter listed it. Three years of answering that address the same day. Live work invoiced monthly. A question at the end of it. Hers the only address on it. All of it in plain sight. What was missing was anything to read those facts and act on them before she arrived.

That’s the whole of the change. Every message is weighed on what’s at stake in it and on when it comes due. The whole mailbox at once, before you sit down. So what’s in front of you when you open the laptop is the few that need you today, with the one that needs you most at the top. It works on the mail that landed last night, whatever lane you set up in March. The reading is done, the ranking is done, and the result is handed to you finished.

That’s what Point does.

What the inbox does before you open it

Point gets to the mail first. Everything that arrived overnight, Point has already been through, the way you’d go through it yourself, in one pass and before you get there. Each message is weighed on both counts, worth and timing. So your feed opens on the handful that need you today rather than on two hundred things stacked newest first. The one that needs you most is at the front of them.

Every long thread arrives with its gist in a sentence. The forty-message back-and-forth that used to cost ten minutes of scrolling is something you take in from the feed itself. When a message wants an answer, a draft comes back written in your voice, and it waits. Replies start at review, which is where every sort of task starts. The words are ready, and the sending stays a decision you make, until you raise that setting yourself. The reply you’re owed and the job you handed off get chased before either goes cold. Fixing a time for a meeting happens in the thread while you get on with your day, and the slot Point settles on comes to you to approve.

You choose how far Point can go, separately for each sort of task, anywhere from suggest-only to handled outright. What Point did while you were away is written up in ordinary words you can read back. Anything Point filed or drafted is one click from being put back.

You keep the address you have. You sign in through Gmail or Microsoft 365, and the account itself stays as it is. The address people write to, the years of history behind it, the people in it: all of that stays where it is. What changes is only who does the weighing. The full list is on the benefits page, and if you want the category rather than this one product, what an AI email client is starts from the ground. What that buys you depends on what your week is made of. There’s a version written for business and executive coaches, one for training providers, and six more besides.

The Tuesday that ends differently

So put the Tuesday back, and leave Nadia exactly as she was.

She’s at her desk by 7:30. The same two hundred and forty messages arrive across the day. She goes through the inbox three times before lunch, because that’s how she works, and that’s how she keeps working.

At eleven the client writes. Three years in, unhappy about something small, not angry, wanting a reply before the day is out. Short and civil, lower case throughout, with no deadline written into it anywhere and nothing on the outside to mark it out from anything else.

In the version that happened, it went in at the top of the list. Inside the hour it sat underneath the newsletters, the receipts and that long thread about the project everyone was going to forget.

This time it goes to the top of her feed and it stays there. It’s worth more to her than anything else that came in that day, and it’s due before the day ends. Beneath the sender, one line: unhappy about the revised timeline, wants a reply today.

She looks at the inbox again before lunch, one of the three passes she always makes, and gives it the same quick glance she gave it the first time round. That glance is where the whole series turns. Last time it took in a sender and a subject line and told her nothing, so she went on down the list, and the screen gave her every reason to. This time it’s enough. The message is first, and the line under it says what it needs. She’s handed the one that matters out of two hundred and forty.

She answers that afternoon. That’s all the note ever wanted, and the whole thing is over.

No call from an account manager, and no second week. The email that opened this series gets dealt with on day one instead of day nine. It happens on an ordinary morning worked properly by a capable person, which is what that morning always was.

That’s the whole of it. Her flagging habit is the same as it was. Her filing is the same. She sorts at the same speed she always did. Nadia’s inbox skills are exactly where they were on Monday. She stopped being the part of it that did the ranking.

So the Tuesday is answered, which was the promise this series opened with. It’s also one Tuesday, and one message, caught in time. The first chapter was blunt about what a single catch is worth: you can count the ones you got to, and the ones still sitting open stay uncounted. A rescued morning is a better story than a lost client, and it’s the same kind of story.

What would settle it is burial having nowhere left to happen. On the mail from senders outside any list you could write in advance. On the mail you set down yourself, month after month, quietly. Whether that’s a real claim or a comfortable one, and how anybody could ever check, is next.

Ready for a calmer inbox?

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.

Private beta

What you're joining

It runs on the mail you have

Point sits on top of Gmail or Outlook. Your address, your history and your contacts stay exactly as they are, so there is nothing to migrate.

You set how much Point does

Out of the box everything waits for your review, replies included. You hand over only what you trust, one kind of work at a time.

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.