Skip to content

Finding the action items buried in your email

On this page

You’re probably catching most of what your email asks of you. The plain requests are easy. Someone writes “can you send the signed copy,” and you see it. The action items that slip are the ones buried in your email in a few predictable places. They sit under the news, or second in a message whose first ask you already answered. Some live inside a sentence that never asks anything at all. Once you know the places, a short sweep turns most of them up.

  • An action item is what a message wants from you. It’s often phrased as a statement, so the question mark won’t give it away.
  • Many messages carry more than one. The second ask is the one that gets lost.
  • People spot asks far better with the whole message in front of them than with a single line.
  • Software helps, and it misses things too. The useful question is how quickly you can see and fix what it got wrong.

Where action items hide in a thread

Here’s a real example from the research, lightly trimmed. A manager writes to three colleagues on a Friday morning. He reminds them a prospective customer is visiting next week. Then comes a five-line schedule, from breakfast at 9:30 to a sales pitch at 3:00. Only after that does he get to it: “I will need each of your parts by Wednesday.”

That message comes from a 2005 study by Paul Bennett and Jaime Carbonell at Carnegie Mellon, Feature Representation for Effective Action-Item Detection, presented at the ACM SIGIR conference. They used it as the model of an action item. It’s a statement, it sits below the fold, and it’s wrapped in a reminder. Nobody reading the preview would see it.

Most missed asks look like that one. They fall into a handful of shapes.

Where it hidesWhat it looks likeWhy it slips past
Under the newsTwo paragraphs of update, then “I’ll need your numbers by Thursday.”The preview and the first lines tell you it’s an update.
Second in the message“Thanks for the draft. Also, could you check the invoice address?”You answer the first thing and archive the thread.
Phrased as a statement“The lease needs your signature before the 15th.”No question mark, so nothing reads as a request.
Inside a condition“If you want to keep the Tuesday slot, confirm by Friday.”It reads as optional, and sometimes it is.
In the quoted text belowAn old ask from three replies back, still sitting in the chain.It may be live, or long since handled. You can’t tell without checking.
In a forward with one line on top“See below, can you handle?” above someone else’s email.The real request is the forwarded message, which you skim.
Aimed at a group“Can someone pull the March figures?” on a reply-all.Everyone assumes someone else has it.
In your own reply“I’ll get that to you Monday.”It’s in your sent mail, where nobody looks for work.

The second-ask problem is bigger than it sounds. Bennett and Carbonell had two people label 744 messages by hand. They found action items in 328 of them. Of those, 69 held more than one separate ask, and one held six. A 2019 Microsoft study looked at what messages are for more broadly, across 1,300 threads from a real company’s mail. About 45% of messages did more than one thing at once. Sharing news and asking a question often appeared together. So did a reminder and a request.

The conditional is the hardest of the shapes, and even trained readers split on it. Bennett and Carbonell’s annotators agreed on whether a message held an ask 93% of the time. When they disagreed, the cause was usually “clear annotator oversight or different interpretations of conditional statements.” Their example makes the problem plain. “If you would like to keep your job, come to tomorrow’s meeting” is an ask. “If you would like to join the football betting pool, come to tomorrow’s meeting” isn’t.

The last row belongs to you. A promise in your sent mail is often the most binding item on the whole list. What it does to the original ask is covered in what turns an ask into a loop you can close.

Why careful readers still miss some

The 2019 Microsoft paper, Context-Aware Intent Identification in Email Conversations, ran a simple test. Wei Wang and four colleagues gave people sentences from real email and asked one question. Is this sentence asking for information? One group saw only the sentence. The other saw the whole message, with the sentence highlighted.

What the reader sawReal asks they foundFlagged sentences that were real asks
The sentence alone52.86%91.51%
The whole message76.61%93.45%

Two things in that table matter for your inbox.

First, when people flagged something, they were almost always right. The error that costs you is the miss. A false alarm is rare.

Second, context is what finds the asks. Reading a line on its own caught about half of them. Reading it inside its message caught about three in four. A preview line, a notification, a subject line: those are all a sentence on its own. That’s why an ask feels obvious once you open the message, and why it went unseen from the list.

Even with the full message, a quarter of real requests went unflagged. These readers were paid crowdworkers looking at strangers’ mail from one tech company, so hold the exact figures loosely. The direction holds for anyone. Reading quickly misses asks, and reading carefully still misses some.

Questions add their own noise. Bennett and Carbonell count a question as a possible action item. They also note that “not all questions are action-items.” Some are rhetorical. Some are “simply social convention,” and their example is “How are you?” Deciding which kind you’re looking at is a judgment about the sender, and that’s the part that takes a moment.

A short sweep for the asks you already have

Say it’s late on a Thursday and you want to know what’s sitting in your mail. Set aside half an hour for two weeks of mail. It works in any mail app.

  1. Pick a window. The last two weeks is enough. Anything older that still matters has usually come back on its own.
  2. Start with threads where the last word isn’t yours. Someone else spoke last, so the next move may be yours.
  3. Open each message and read past the first paragraph. The table above says why. The ask is often in the third paragraph, after the update.
  4. Ask one question of each message. What does this want from me, and by when? If the answer has two parts, write down two items.
  5. Search for the words asks use. Try “can you,” “could you,” “please,” “need,” “by Friday” and “let me know.” Search finds the phrase and skips the preview problem.
  6. Search your sent mail for “I’ll” and “I will.” Those are your promises. Count them as action items too.
  7. Write each one where you’ll see it, with a link back to the thread. The link matters. A line like “send the figures” loses which figures within a week.

Some of what you find will be old news. The client sorted it on a call, or a colleague answered it. That’s fine. Crossing it off is still a finding, and it’s quicker than wondering.

A sweep like this catches what’s there today. It doesn’t keep tomorrow’s asks from piling up. For that, the finding has to happen when the mail lands. That’s the case for having software do the reading.

What your email app already finds

The tools built into Gmail and Outlook mostly help after you’ve spotted the ask yourself. Here’s what each one does about an action item, from the providers’ own pages and coverage of them.

ToolWhat it doesWho does the spotting
Gmail Add to TasksTurns an open email into a Google Task with a link back, per this Oakland University guideYou
Gmail nudgesReminds you to reply to or follow up on a message, since the April 2018 redesignGmail picks the thread. The ask inside it is yours to find
Outlook flagsMarks a message for follow-up on a date and lets you tick it off, per this IT services guideYou
Copilot in OutlookSummarizes a thread from a button at the top. Microsoft also suggests asking it to identify key actionsCopilot drafts a list when asked
Gemini in GmailSummarizes threads and helps draft repliesGemini, inside a summary

A summary and an action item answer different questions, and the difference costs real work. A summary gives you the gist of a thread. An action item is what the thread wants from you. A good summary can cover a thread fully and still leave the one ask in paragraph three out. A plain summary of every email covers what a summary is for. Which threads reach you first is a separate job again, and how email triage works covers it.

If you want the software options laid side by side, the best email task tools for a small firm compares the kinds. Forwarding mail into Asana or Todoist has its own guide.

How Point reads a thread for asks

Point is an email client, and it reads every thread when the mail lands. That means the sweep above happens on each message, without you. Where a message wants something from you, Point drafts a task for it. A date comes along when the thread names one. So does a link to the exact words that asked.

Take the manager’s message from earlier. Point would read past the schedule and land on “each of your parts by Wednesday.” It would turn that into a task due Wednesday, tied to the thread.

What happens next depends on how you’ve set task creation.

  • Suggest-only. Point shows the ask it found. You decide whether it becomes a task.
  • Review. Point prepares the task and holds it for your yes. This is where every kind of action starts out of the box.
  • Handled outright. Point puts the task straight on your list.

You can change the setting for tasks without touching how Point handles replies or scheduling. Each kind of action has its own.

Point misses things too, and it helps to know where. It sees what came through your mail. An ask made on a call or in a hallway never reaches it. It can’t know the client canceled this morning by phone. A conditional ask is a judgment call for software, just as it was for Bennett and Carbonell’s readers. An ask that lives only inside an attachment is worth checking yourself. So the link back to the thread matters. When a task looks wrong, the sender’s own words are one tap away.

How the date gets chosen, and what Point does when you’ve already finished something, is covered in email task management, without writing it down. For everything else Point does with your mail, see the benefits page.

Common questions

What counts as an action item in an email?

Anything in a message that wants something from you. That covers doing a task, sending something, deciding, replying with an answer or showing up somewhere. It often arrives as a statement rather than a question, like “the form needs your signature.” A question can be an action item too. “How are you?” usually isn’t.

Why do I keep missing action items in long email threads?

Most often the ask sits after an update, or comes second in a message. In a long thread it can also hide in quoted text from an earlier reply. Research from Microsoft found people caught about half of the real requests for information when reading a sentence alone, and about three in four with the whole message. Opening the message and reading past the first paragraph does most of the work.

Can AI find every action item in my email?

No. Trained human readers disagree on some asks, especially conditional ones, and software inherits that difficulty. It also only sees what reached your mailbox, so asks made on a call are invisible to it. Look for a tool that shows each ask next to the words it came from, so a wrong one takes seconds to fix.

Are emails I’m only copied on likely to have action items for me?

Sometimes. A cc’d message can name you in the body, or ask the group something that lands on you by default. A quick search of cc’d mail for your own name finds most of them. If a group ask is genuinely unclear, a one-line reply asking who’s taking it settles the question.

How often should I sweep my inbox for action items?

A short weekly sweep is enough for most small firms, if asks are also being caught as mail arrives. If you’re doing all the finding by hand, a daily ten minutes on the day’s threads keeps the pile from forming. Writing down an ask the moment you read it beats any sweep.

What should I do with an action item once I’ve found it?

Put it on one list with a link to its thread and a date if there is one. From there it’s a commitment to manage, and what turns an ask into a loop you can close takes it from that point. If you’re the one sending the ask, how to ask someone to do something in an email is the place to start.

Ready for a calmer inbox?

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.

Private beta

What you're joining

It runs on the mail you have

Point sits on top of Gmail or Outlook. Your address, your history and your contacts stay exactly as they are, so there is nothing to migrate.

You set how much Point does

Out of the box everything waits for your review, replies included. You hand over only what you trust, one kind of work at a time.

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.