Skip to content

The scare email that made you go looking for something safer

Part 01 of 7

On this page

The scare email didn’t look like much. It was a reply from a client, sent at 8:41 on a Tuesday, and it said thanks.

“Thanks for the heads-up on the new bank details. I’ll send the retainer over this afternoon. Just confirming before I do.”

Maya Okafor runs a six-person bookkeeping and tax practice in Columbus. She hadn’t changed the firm’s bank details. She hadn’t written to Dale Huang about his retainer in three weeks. Somebody had, from her address, inside the thread they’d been using since March.

This series follows Maya’s firm through the two weeks after that email. It’s for anyone who’s had a moment like hers and opened a tab to look for a safer email provider. The first week is the lockdown. The second is what held. At the end of it she still has the same address and the same provider. The account under it is a lot harder to get into. This first part is the morning itself: what the email meant, how she found out, and what she learned that night about where break-ins actually come from.

The series comes from Point, an assistant that works inside the mail a firm already has. What Point does is its own read. Everything here holds whichever app you open your mail in.

A reply to a message she never sent

Her first thought was the ordinary one. Somebody’s faking my address.

That happens, and it’s the better of the two outcomes. Anyone can put a name and an address in the “from” line of a message, the way anyone can write a return address on an envelope. A spoofed message never touches your account. It’s a forgery sent from somewhere else.

Her second thought came a few seconds later. The message was in the thread. Dale’s reply quoted it underneath his own, and above that it quoted her real message from three weeks ago, word for word. A forger working from the outside doesn’t usually have your last message to Dale. Somebody reading her mail does.

That’s the line worth knowing if you’re where Maya was. A message with your name on it that arrives cold, with nothing of yours quoted, may be a forgery. A message that carries on one of your real conversations, in your real thread, means someone has probably read the thread. The FTC lists exactly this as one of the signs an account has been taken over:

Your friends or family report getting emails or messages you didn’t send.

That’s from the FTC’s guide to recovering a hacked email account. The same page notes that your email is the key to your other accounts. Anyone who holds it can reset the passwords on everything tied to it.

The first hour

Maya didn’t touch her keyboard for the first five minutes. She picked up the phone.

She called Dale at the number in her client file, not the one in the email signature. He hadn’t sent anything yet. She asked him to delete the message and to call her before acting on anything about money from her address, for the rest of the month. He laughed and said he’d been half-expecting a call. Something about “new bank details” in a thread about a lease review had felt off. That half-second of doubt saved him the retainer. Most of what follows in this series is about not needing it next time.

Then she opened her sent folder. There was nothing in it to Dale since that message three weeks ago, and the forged one wasn’t there either. Whoever sent it had deleted it afterward.

Then she found the rule.

Under her settings, among the filters she’d made years ago for newsletters, was one she’d never made. Any message with “invoice,” “payment” or “wire” in it was forwarded to an outside address and then archived. It had been running for eleven days. Every message in that time that mentioned money had gone somewhere else first, and then out of her sight.

The FTC’s October 29, 2024, alert on hacked email names this exact thing:

Check if there are auto-forwarding rules in your email account that you didn’t set up. Hackers might create these rules to forward your emails to another address.

The rest of her hour followed the same alert closely. She made a new password, long and used nowhere else. She signed the account out of every device, so whoever was in it was put out too. She checked the recovery phone number and recovery address, and found they were still hers. She deleted the rule. Then she ran Google’s Security Checkup, which lists recent sign-ins and security events in one place.

The sign-in was there. A Saturday, eleven days earlier, from a browser and a city she’d never used. The password had been entered correctly the first time. There was no second step to get past, because her own account was the one in the firm that had never had one turned on.

By 9:45 the door was shut. She was shaken, and nobody had lost a dollar.

What a scare email is telling you

It’s worth naming what Maya actually learned that morning. It’s a smaller and more useful lesson than the one a scare usually teaches.

The email told her that someone had her password. It didn’t tell her that her provider had been broken into. Nobody broke into Google that Saturday. Somebody signed in as Maya, through the front door, with her key.

Most account break-ins look like this. Someone signs in with a password that got out somewhere else, or with one typed into a page that only looked like the real one. Maya’s turned out to be the first kind. The password on her email matched the one she’d used for a conference registration site years before. That site had lost its user list.

It’s also why the forwarding rule matters more than the message. The message to Dale was the visible part. The rule was the patient part. It had been reading every invoice thread for a week and a half, waiting for the right one to answer. That’s the usual shape of what the FBI calls business email compromise: read first, then reply inside a real conversation, at the moment money is about to move.

Which email gets hacked the least?

That night Maya did what most people do after a morning like hers. She typed a question into a search box. It was close to this one.

The honest answer is that the brand is rarely the deciding factor. Big providers do get attacked all the time. But the break-ins that reach a small firm’s inbox mostly come through the person signing in. Verizon’s 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report looked at 12,195 confirmed breaches. It found that stolen or misused credentials were the most common way in:

credential abuse (22%) and exploitation of vulnerabilities (20%) continue to be the leading initial attack vectors

The same report notes “a significant overlap between social engineering and credential abuse.” In plain terms, people get talked or tricked out of their passwords, and then the passwords get used.

The money side tells the same story. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center received 21,442 complaints about business email compromise in 2024, with losses close to $2.8 billion. That’s as reported by Nacha, citing the 2024 IC3 annual report. Those losses don’t depend on which company hosts the mailbox. They depend on someone getting into it, or convincingly pretending to be in it.

So the question that actually separates a safer inbox from a less safe one is a different one. How hard is it for someone holding your password to get in anyway? And who else, besides you, can already open it? Both of those are settings on the account you have now. Neither one changes when you move to a new provider.

What changed by Tuesday night

By the evening Maya had a few things she hadn’t had at breakfast.

  • A clean account. New password, every session signed out, the rule gone.
  • A timeline. One sign-in on a Saturday, eleven days of forwarding, one message to Dale.
  • A short list of people to call. Every client whose thread mentioned money in those eleven days heard from her by phone the next morning.
  • A doubt. If her account was that easy to get into, how many of the other five were?

She also had a feeling she couldn’t argue with. She’d built the firm on that address. Clients had it on their invoices and in their phones. And for eleven days someone else had been reading it before she did.

You’re allowed to feel that. Plenty of owners have been exactly here. A reused password from an old site is one of the most ordinary things in the world. So is an owner whose own account is the last one to get the extra protection, because she was busy setting it up for everybody else.

At 7:50 on Wednesday, Priya, the firm’s office manager, sent Maya three links. Each one was a list of the most secure email providers. One had a table with padlocks in it. Priya had written one line above them.

“Should we just move?”

It’s the right question to ask after a morning like Tuesday’s. It’s also a bigger decision than it looks, with a cost that lands on every client who has the address. Maya didn’t answer that morning. First she wanted to know what switching buys you, and what it doesn’t.

Ready for a calmer inbox?

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.

Private beta

What you're joining

It runs on the mail you have

Point sits on top of Gmail or Outlook. Your address, your history and your contacts stay exactly as they are, so there is nothing to migrate.

You set how much Point does

Out of the box everything waits for your review, replies included. You hand over only what you trust, one kind of work at a time.

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.