Skip to content

What secure email means, and what it protects

On this page

Secure email is email protected in three places: the account, the message, and the inbox. The account is protected when only you can sign in. The message is protected when it’s encrypted on the way and in storage, and sometimes so that only the recipient can open it. The inbox is protected when forged and malicious mail gets filtered out before you see it. Every product sold as secure email does some of this. None does all of it, and the useful question is which threats each one covers.

  • If you use Gmail or Outlook, you already have the baseline. Mail is encrypted between servers and on the provider’s disks.
  • What the baseline leaves open is the provider itself, plus anyone who gets into your account.
  • Secure email providers like Proton close the first gap for stored mail. They don’t close the second, and they bring trade-offs of their own.
  • The threat that empties the most inboxes is a stolen password. That’s fixed in your account settings, whichever provider you’re on.

The rest of this page sets out each model, what it protects, and where to go once you know what you need.

What is secure email?

The phrase covers two jobs that are easy to blur. The US standards body draws the line itself. NIST Special Publication 800-177 Rev. 1, “Trustworthy Email,” was published in February 2019. It recommends SPF, DKIM and DMARC for proving which domain a message really came from. Then it treats content as its own concern:

Recommendations for email content security include the encryption and authentication of message content using S/MIME

So one half of secure email is about trust. Did this message really come from your bank, and can a forger use your domain? The other half is about secrecy. Who can read this message, on the way and once it’s stored? Security vendors that sell filtering mean the first half. Encrypted mail services mean the second. Both are right, and a reader comparing them should know which half each page is talking about.

There’s a third piece neither half covers, and it’s the one that matters most day to day. That’s the account. If someone signs in as you, every protection on the message is opened for them, the same way it opens for you.

The four models, in one line each

Almost every secure email product falls into one of four models. The difference between them is who holds the key that turns stored mail back into readable text. How each kind of encryption works is set out in the kinds of encryption, side by side.

ModelWhat it isWho can read stored mailExamples
Transport only (TLS)Mail is encrypted between servers, then stored readable to the providerYou and the providerStandard Gmail, Outlook, most business mail
Provider-held encryptionThe provider encrypts the message and releases it to whoever signs in or enters a codeYou, the provider, and the recipient once they authenticateGmail confidential mode, Microsoft Purview Message Encryption, bank portals
Zero-access storageMail is stored encrypted with a key derived from your password, which the provider doesn’t holdYou only, for message bodiesProton Mail, Tuta
End-to-end (PGP, S/MIME)The sender encrypts to the recipient’s key before the message leavesSender and recipient onlyPGP, S/MIME, Proton-to-Proton mail, Gmail client-side encryption

Zero-access and end-to-end overlap inside services like Proton. Mail between two Proton users is end-to-end. Mail arriving from Gmail is zero-access once Proton stores it.

What each model protects, and what it doesn’t

This is the table most comparison pages skip. Each row is a thing someone might want to keep private, or a way things go wrong. Each column is a model.

What’s at stakeTransport only (TLS)Provider-held encryptionZero-access storageEnd-to-end (PGP, S/MIME)
Message body, in transitProtected between servers that both support TLSProtectedProtectedProtected
Message body, stored with the providerReadable by the providerReadable by the providerProtectedProtected
AttachmentsSame as the bodySame as the bodyProtectedProtected
Subject lineReadable by the providerDepends on the productEncrypted, but not end-to-endUsually exposed
Who wrote to whom, and whenReadable by the providerReadable by the providerReadable by the providerReadable by both providers
Mail to someone on ordinary emailSame as any mailRecipient reads it through a link or codeArrives readable to their providerOnly works if they have a key
Your own device, compromisedExposedExposedExposedExposed
Your password, phishedExposedExposedExposed, if the password unlocks the keyExposed, if the key is on a device the attacker reaches
A court order to the providerProvider can hand over readable mailProvider can hand over readable mailBodies stay encrypted; metadata can be handed overBodies stay encrypted; metadata can be handed over

Three rows deserve a sentence each.

Subject lines and metadata. Proton is open about this. Its encryption overview (checked October 4, 2026) says bodies and attachments are stored end-to-end encrypted. Then it says:

Subject lines, recipient email addresses, and sender email addresses are encrypted, but not end-to-end encrypted.

The reason is the standard. In OpenPGP, Proton explains, “the subject line is part of the header packet, which is not end-to-end encrypted.” A sensitive subject line is the most common leak in otherwise encrypted mail. Write subjects as if they’ll be read.

Mail to people on ordinary email. Encryption covers the whole trip only when both ends take part. Proton’s own page says that once a message reaches a non-Proton recipient, “it isn’t end-to-end encrypted by default. So the recipient’s email provider may be able to access it.” Most of a small firm’s mail goes to clients on Gmail and Outlook. For them, a secure provider protects your copy, and their copy sits where their mail always sits.

The device and the password. Every column says exposed, and that’s the honest answer. Encryption protects mail from people who don’t have your keys. A phished password or an infected laptop gives the attacker your keys. That’s why the next section matters more than the choice of provider.

What is the most hacked email provider?

The providers that show up most in breach data are the biggest ones. Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo top the lists because they hold the most addresses. Breach lists track how many people use a service, not how weak it is.

Troy Hunt runs Have I Been Pwned, the service most people use to check their address against leaked data. In October 2025, he loaded a corpus of nearly 2 billion addresses. Gmail was the largest of 32 million domains in it, at 394 million addresses. He was plain about what that meant:

the 20% of Gmail addresses have absolutely nothing to do with any sort of security vulnerability on Google’s behalf.

Those addresses came from malware on people’s own computers and from passwords reused across sites. Two kinds of evidence point the same way:

  • Microsoft’s 2025 Digital Defense Report says “more than 97% of identity attacks are password attacks.” It says phishing-resistant multifactor authentication can stop over 99% of them.
  • Verizon’s 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report found stolen credentials were the way in for 22% of breaches. That’s the largest single share. Phishing accounted for about 15% more.

Providers do get breached themselves, and it’s fair to know when. Two cases stand out:

  • Yahoo. In an October 3, 2017, filing, Yahoo said “all Yahoo user accounts were affected by the August 2013 theft.” That was about 3 billion accounts. The stolen data included hashed passwords and some security questions.
  • Microsoft. The Cyber Safety Review Board’s March 20, 2024, report covered a 2023 intrusion. A state-linked group reached the Exchange Online mailboxes of 22 organizations and over 500 people. The board found the intrusion preventable and Microsoft’s security culture “inadequate.”

Both are rare compared with account takeover. So the email least likely to be hacked is the account with a unique password, a passkey or security key, and current recovery details. That holds on any major provider.

Is Outlook or Gmail more secure?

At the level most people use them, they’re close. Both encrypt mail between servers and on their disks. Both filter spam and phishing. The real differences sit in the paid business tiers.

Gmail and Google WorkspaceOutlook and Microsoft 365
In transit“All Gmail messages use TLS automatically” (Google)“With Microsoft 365, your data is encrypted at rest and in transit” (Microsoft)
At restEncrypted by default, with Google holding the keys (Google)Encrypted with BitLocker in Microsoft data centers, with Microsoft holding the keys (Microsoft)
Built-in protected messageConfidential mode: expiry, revoke access, block forwarding, optional SMS passcode (Google)Purview Message Encryption, included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium (Microsoft)
Keys the provider can’t useClient-side encryption, on Workspace Enterprise Plus with the Assured Controls add-on (Google, October 2025)Double Key Encryption, which comes with Microsoft 365 E5 (Microsoft)
Reading mail for ads“We will not scan or read your Gmail messages to show you ads” (Google)Not stated on the pages checked

All checked October 4, 2026. Two notes on the table.

Confidential mode isn’t end-to-end encryption. Google says so on its own help page:

While confidential mode can help prevent recipients from accidentally sharing emails, they can still take screenshots or photos of your emails. Recipients with malicious programs may still be able to copy or download your messages.

The keys-the-provider-can’t-use row is the only one where either company steps out of its own way. Both put it in enterprise plans that most small firms don’t buy. On the plans small firms do buy, the honest answer is a tie, and the account settings decide the rest. How to send one protected message from each is covered in sending securely from Gmail and sending securely from Microsoft 365.

Secure cloud email, gateways and self-hosting

Secure email also comes in three shapes, depending on where the mail lives:

  • Secure cloud email is a hosted service like Proton, Tuta or an encrypted Workspace setup. The provider runs the servers. Who holds the keys depends on the model above.
  • A secure email gateway sits in front of an existing mail system and filters what comes in and goes out. It protects the inbox half: phishing, malware, forged senders. It usually leaves stored mail as readable as before.
  • Self-hosting means running your own mail server. You hold every key, and you also own every patch, every backup and every deliverability problem.

For a small firm, the first is the realistic choice and the third rarely is. The full comparison of where mail can sit, and who can reach it there, is in where your mail sits.

What Proton Mail costs you in practice

Proton is the name most people meet first, and its zero-access model is real. The trade-offs are just as real. They come from Proton’s own documentation, all checked October 4, 2026.

  • Search. Proton’s servers can’t read your message bodies, so they can’t search them. Body search runs from an index built in your browser. Proton says you “must create an index of your messages for each browser on each device.” Clearing your browser data erases it.
  • Desktop mail apps. Apple Mail, Outlook and Thunderbird connect through Proton Mail Bridge, a separate app on your computer. The plans page lists Bridge and IMAP support under Proton Mail Plus, not the free plan.
  • Legal requests. Proton is in Switzerland and answers to Swiss courts. Its transparency report lists 9,301 legal orders for Proton Mail in 2025. It contested 988 and complied with 8,313. It also says “all emails, files and invites are encrypted and we have no means to decrypt them.” So what goes out is the unencrypted layer: account details, subject lines, metadata.
  • IP addresses. Proton’s privacy policy says it doesn’t keep permanent IP logs by default. It also says “IP logs may be kept temporarily to combat abuse and fraud.”
  • Your correspondents. Mail to clients on Gmail and Outlook arrives readable to their provider, as the matrix shows.

Proton fits when you need what it protects: stored mail kept from the provider and from a court order for content. The price is search, desktop-app ease and some everyday convenience.

Is Proton Mail still free?

Yes. As of October 4, 2026, Proton’s plans page lists Proton Mail Free with:

  • 1 email address
  • Up to 1 GB of mail storage, which starts at 500 MB and grows when you finish its get-started steps
  • A send limit of 150 messages a day
  • No custom domain, and no Bridge for desktop mail apps

That suits a personal address. For a business, the domain and Bridge limits usually push you to a paid plan. The free options across providers are compared in free secure email.

How do I create a secure email?

There are two routes, and most people need the first one whichever they choose.

Secure the account you already have. This closes the gap that empties the most inboxes:

  1. Use a password you don’t use anywhere else, kept in a password manager.
  2. Turn on two-step verification, and use a passkey or security key if your provider offers one.
  3. Keep your recovery phone and backup address current, so you can get back in and an attacker can’t.
  4. Review which apps and devices are signed in, and remove the ones you don’t recognize.

Open an address with an encrypted provider. This adds zero-access storage and end-to-end mail with other users of the same service. Who sells it is in the secure email companies. Using your own domain with one is covered in a secure address on your own domain. Whether switching is worth it for your firm at all is a decision of its own, and what a more secure provider would actually buy you walks through it.

What’s the most secure email to have?

The most secure setup combines a provider that can’t read your stored mail with sign-in that can’t be phished. For one person, that’s an end-to-end provider with a security key. For a firm, it’s usually a business plan whose admin can enforce two-step verification for everyone, with encryption added for the messages that need it.

The providers are compared on what each actually protects in the most secure email, ranked honestly. For firms choosing a business service, start with secure email for your business. If you’d rather keep your current provider and add encryption, encryption a small firm can run covers what that takes.

Where an assistant fits

Point isn’t an email provider, and it doesn’t encrypt mail. It works on the Gmail or Outlook account you already have, so every protection on this page stays exactly as you set it. It never needs your email password. What it does on top of that account is set out on what Point does for you. That leaves one real tension. Whatever keeps a provider out of a message also keeps any assistant out, Point included. That trade is covered in encrypted email, and what an AI assistant cannot read.

Common questions

Is secure email the same as encrypted email?

Mostly, but not quite. Encrypted email is one part of secure email: it protects the message. Secure email also covers the account, so only you can sign in, and the inbox, so forged and malicious mail gets filtered. A service can be encrypted and still be easy to break into with a reused password.

Is Gmail secure email?

Gmail encrypts mail between servers and on Google’s disks, and it filters spam and phishing. Google holds the keys, so it isn’t end-to-end encrypted by default. That’s secure against outsiders on the network and weaker against anyone who signs in as you.

Can secure email be hacked?

Yes, mostly through the account rather than the encryption. A phished password, a reused password or malware on your device opens encrypted mail the same way it opens for you. Phishing-resistant sign-in, like a passkey or security key, is the single strongest protection.

Does encryption hide who I email?

No. In every model, the provider can see sender, recipient and time, because it needs them to deliver mail. Proton encrypts sender and recipient addresses in storage, but not end-to-end.

Is secure email required for HIPAA?

The HIPAA Security Rule asks covered entities and business associates to safeguard electronic health information, and encryption is one of those safeguards. What that means for a practice’s email is covered in secure email for your business.

Ready for a calmer inbox?

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.

Private beta

What you're joining

It runs on the mail you have

Point sits on top of Gmail or Outlook. Your address, your history and your contacts stay exactly as they are, so there is nothing to migrate.

You set how much Point does

Out of the box everything waits for your review, replies included. You hand over only what you trust, one kind of work at a time.

Join the private beta

We're onboarding a few teams at a time. Leave your email, confirm it once, and we'll send an invitation the moment a place opens.

By joining you agree to our privacy policy.